Political ad grabs attention of Iowa's top court

2014-01-23T18:00:00Z 2014-03-13T14:25:15Z Political ad grabs attention of Iowa's top courtMike Wiser Times Bureau The Quad-City Times

DES MOINES — The Iowa Supreme Court waded into the murky waters where political ads, defamation of character and the First Amendment mix in case involving a Republican state senator from Sioux City and his 2010 Democratic opponent.

“This is how you change the face of politics,” state Sen. Rick Bertrand, R-Sioux City, said standing just outside the courtroom doors immediately after his hearing in front a five-judge panel.

“I think Iowa has an opportunity, once again, to lead the nation,” he said. “It’s an opportunity for this court to say, ‘Enough is enough,’ that at some point, you can’t say just anything with the intention of malice behind it and get away with it.”

He successfully sued Rick Mullin and the Iowa Democratic Party over a 2010 campaign ad that claimed Bertrand “put profits ahead of children’s health.”

The claim was based on Bertrand’s former job as a regional manager for biotech company Takeda North America, the U.S. unit of Japan's Takeda Pharmaceutical Co.

A jury awarded Bertrand $231,000 in damages. District Judge Jeffrey Poulson later reduced that award to $50,000.

Mullin appealed the initial verdict, and Bertrand appealed the reduced award amount.

Juustice David Wiggins seemed skeptical there was a clear case of defamation, saying the ad could be interpreted as saying Takeda, not Bertrand himself or the businesses he currently runs, were the ones selling controversial medicine.

“It was pretty clear in the ad, to me at least,” he said.

Bertand’s attorney, Jeana Goosmann, agreed if the ad had said Takeda, “we may have had a different case.” But, she said, the ad didn’t say that.

“The standard (for defamation) is high,” she said. “It has been met.”

Chief Justice Mark Cady asked Goosmann if the court would “suppress the First Amendment by affirming this.” She responded that holding up Bertrand’s award would “help clean up politics.”

Juustice Thomas Waterman suggested that if the court doesn’t hold up the award, “good people” would be turned off of politics for fear there was no recourse against those who would “sully” their names in the course of a political campaign.

Des Moines attorney Mark McCormick, who represented both Mullins and the Iowa Democratic Party, said the case was bigger than “just Iowa” and it represented the “combat of ideas” inherent in political speech.

“Actual malice is a very high threshold,” he said. “We’re talking about the First Amendment to the Constitution.”

The court will issue its decision at a later date.

Copyright 2016 The Quad-City Times. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

(1) Comments

  1. longjohn412
    Report Abuse
    longjohn412 - January 24, 2014 6:55 am
    If this flies does that mean President Obamas can sue Senator Grasley for his lies about Obama supporting "Death Panels for Seniors"?

    Or how about any Iowa Republican falsely claiming he was born in Kenya or lies he isn't a Christian but a Muslim.....

    And cripes the Swiftboat Defamers would all have been sued by Kerry if they showed ads in Iowa .....

    This could really come back to bite the GOP in a Big Way .......
Add Comment
You must Login to comment.

Click here to get an account it's free and quick

Gaul, Cullen honored with Iowa journalism awards

Gaul, Cullen honored with Iowa journalism awards

Quad-City Times reporters Alma Gaul and Jack Cullen were recognized by their peers on Friday when representatives of Iowa’s daily and weekly n…

9 hours ago Photos

Photos

(0)

8 things to know about Davenport's $201.7 million budget

8 things to know about Davenport's $201.7 million budget

Davenport city leaders are looking to pull a few more dollars out of the pockets of property owners and residents as it seeks to raise fees in…

10 hours ago Photos

Photos

(1)

Home show opens weekend run in RI

Home show opens weekend run in RI

The 39th annual Quad-Cities Builders and Remodelers Association Home Show offers just about everything you would need for your home and yard.

11 hours ago Photos

Photos

(0)

Audit identifies spending issues in Davenport fire accounts

Audit identifies spending issues in Davenport fire accounts

The Iowa state Auditor's Office said Friday it has identified more than $4,000 in improper or undocumented spending between 2009 and 2014 in t…

11 hours ago(0)

Scattered flurries and a low of 24

Scattered flurries and a low of 24

Good evening, Quad-Cities. Here is your National Weather Service forecast.

12 hours ago Video Related (0)

Clinton sheriff to run for re-election

Clinton sheriff to run for re-election

CLINTON, Iowa — Clinton County Sheriff Rick Lincoln has announced he will seek a fifth term as sheriff.

12 hours ago(0)

Party insider: Dems should consider GOP-style voting

Party insider: Dems should consider GOP-style voting

DES MOINES — Iowa Democrats should consider altering their presidential precinct caucus procedures to look more like the vote conducted by Rep…

13 hours ago(1)

Drivers in fatal drag race crash plead guilty

Drivers in fatal drag race crash plead guilty

A Carbon Cliff teen and Davenport man have pleaded guilty to charges stemming from a double-fatal crash in October.

14 hours ago(1)

New Q-C website promotes trail exploration

New Q-C website promotes trail exploration

Before October, Lisa Miller hadn’t hopped on her bicycle for an extended cruise for about a decade.

15 hours ago Photos

Photos

(1)

On Iowa Politics: A caucus wrap-up

On Iowa Politics: A caucus wrap-up

This week on the podcast, reporters talk who won the Democratic caucuses, should there be a GOP do-over and if Iowa will hold its first-in-the…

15 hours ago Related (0)

Mayor Klipsch's 5 issues in 30 days

Mayor Klipsch's 5 issues in 30 days

Davenport Mayor Frank Klipsch used his first-ever mayoral briefing Friday to update the community on five of the issues he has dealt with in h…

15 hours ago(6)

Google finds star doodler in PV second-grade classroom

Google finds star doodler in PV second-grade classroom

When Shalini Chandupatla was just a toddler, she started to doodle. And doodle.

15 hours ago Photos

Photos

(1)

Rock Island Arsenal Museum to reduce collection, operations

Rock Island Arsenal Museum to reduce collection, operations

About 3,200 artifacts will be removed from the Rock Island Arsenal Museum's collection amid an upcoming reduction in staff.

16 hours ago Related (3)

Attempt to delay Iowa Medicaid management rules fails

Attempt to delay Iowa Medicaid management rules fails

DES MOINES — The state will proceed with planning for private management of Iowa’s $5 billion Medicaid program after a legislative rule-making…

16 hours ago Photos

Photos

(1)

Iowa warned that 'party school image' is hurting credibility

Iowa warned that 'party school image' is hurting credibility

IOWA CITY — A Republican pollster warned the University of Iowa a year ago that its public standing was suffering from an image as a heavy-dri…

23 hours ago Related (7)

Prosecutor seeks review of sentence for 'best meth cook'

Prosecutor seeks review of sentence for 'best meth cook'

ALEDO, Ill. — Just two days after a Taylor Ridge man was placed on three years probation in a Mercer County methamphetamine case, Mercer Count…

February 05, 2016 5:00 am(6)

Looking back: Remember the Vale?

Looking back: Remember the Vale?

Remember the Vale Apartments in downtown Davenport across from the Blackhawk Hotel on 4th and Perry streets?

February 05, 2016 5:00 am Related (11)

Sewer project closes Pershing Blvd. in Clinton

Sewer project closes Pershing Blvd. in Clinton

The City of Clinton reports that portions of Pershing Boulevard will be closed  for a sewer project beginning Feb. 5.

February 05, 2016 5:00 am(0)

Sentencing postponed in Davenport stabbing death

Sentencing postponed in Davenport stabbing death

A sentencing hearing scheduled Thursday for convicted murderer Gary M. Fortune was postponed until Feb. 18.

February 05, 2016 4:45 am Photos

Photos

(0)

Some scattered snow on horizon

Some scattered snow on horizon

A good Friday to all. The next few days bring that proverbial "mixed bag" of weather conditions to the Quad-Cities — clouds, sun, scattered fl…

February 05, 2016 4:41 am Video Related (0)