Lead shot threatens eagles, study says

2014-06-05T04:30:00Z 2014-06-05T05:25:09Z Lead shot threatens eagles, study saysAlma Gaul agaul@qctimes.com The Quad-City Times
June 05, 2014 4:30 am  • 

Bald eagles are dying because they are eating the remains of deer that have been shot using lead ammunition, according to a two-year study conducted by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service.

The findings will be presented Tuesday, June 10, during an informational session at the Thomson, Ill., visitor center of the Upper Mississippi River National Wildlife and Fish Refuge.

Ed Britton, the manager of the refuge's Savanna, Ill., district, said the study tested the livers of 168 dead eagles collected from the refuge over a two-year period and found that 48 percent had detectable concentrations of lead while 21 percent had concentrations considered lethal.

"Additionally, most of the eagles exhibited physical signs consistent with lead exposure," he said.

The 240,000-acre refuge covers parts of Iowa, Illinois, Minnesota and Wisconsin along the Mississippi River.

To show that eagles find and eat deer, researchers deposited road-kill deer in an area with motion detectors, and "the eagles found them right away," Britton said.

That being the case, eagles also could be expected to quickly find deer gut piles — the internal parts of deer that hunters typically leave behind after they field-dress deer they have slain.

And gut piles contain lead. As part of the study, researchers collected 25 gut piles from managed hunts in the Lost Mound Unit of the refuge during 2012 and '13, and they found that 36 percent of the piles contained from one to 107 lead fragments per pile, Britton said.

"During winter months when fish are not readily accessible, eagles rely on carrion, including deer carcasses and gut piles, as a primary food source," he said.

"With thousands of bald eagles wintering and hundreds of eagles nesting on the refuge, we are concerned with the potential long-term impacts of the occurrence of lethal lead levels documented in the study," he added.

"We are also concerned that other wildlife that feed on wounded, but not retrieved, deer, discarded deer parts and deer gut piles are being exposed to lead." 

"Most hunters are conservationists at heart," Britton said, adding that he hopes that when they see the data, they will switch to non-lead ammunition.

Although all metals are toxic, alternative metals don't fragment as much as lead, Britton explained. The chances of an eagle eating large chunks of metal are much less than with small pellets, he added.

The possibility of limiting lead ammunition by law or regulation is "very controversial," he said. 

Ed Kocal, the Quad-City area conservation officer for the Iowa Department of Natural Resources, said he does not know of any deer hunters around the Quad-City region who use non-lead ammunition. It is relatively new, difficult to find and more expensive than lead, he added.

"A lot of hunters would be against that (a restriction on lead) because of the cost," he said. Asked whether some would view it as a back-door method of gun control, he said, "Unfortunately, that's going to be the reaction of a lot of people."

The refuge study is not the first to link spent ammunition and lead poisoning in other wildlife; studies conducted throughout the United States as well as internationally have shown ammunition to be a pathway, Britton said.

Copyright 2016 The Quad-City Times. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

(8) Comments

  1. iverburl
    Report Abuse
    iverburl - June 14, 2014 4:25 pm
    One need only read the lame arguments offered in favor of lead ammo (by leading industry groups) to see that it is a practice with no logical defense.

    On cost of non-lead ammo: Deer hunters have found that while the ammo costs more per round, they spend less because it is more accurate and they fire fewer rounds. Bravo to NFWS for gathering solid data and speaking truth rather than kowtowing to reactionary groups. Now it's time for other government agencies (Iowa DNR) to do the same.
  2. TruthOnlyBeTold
    Report Abuse
    TruthOnlyBeTold - June 05, 2014 6:04 pm
    "And gut piles contain lead. As part of the study, researchers collected 25 gut piles from managed hunts in the Lost Mound Unit of the refuge during 2012 and '13, and they found that 36 percent of the piles contained from one to 107 lead fragments per pile, Britton said."


    They went through all those guts and counted the lead fragments? Nasty!
  3. Lou Ford
    Report Abuse
    Lou Ford - June 05, 2014 5:39 pm
    Nyuk nyuk nyuk
  4. Um_whatever
    Report Abuse
    Um_whatever - June 05, 2014 3:02 pm
    Murica!
  5. pwesselius
    Report Abuse
    pwesselius - June 05, 2014 2:15 pm
    Lead is a potent neurotoxin that accumulates in the body over time and does not get excreted like other toxins. Lead was removed from paint in 1978, removed from (new) plumbing in 1986, removed from solder in food cans in 1995, and completely removed from automobile gasoline in 1996. Today, pending regulations seek to remove lead from Aviation gasoline (avgas). It comes as no surprise to me that lead is harmful to eagles. It's also harmful to humans and we should make an effort to completely remove it from our products. Solid copper bullets may be more expensive, but copper has better ductile deformation and it's a harder metal. I've been using solid copper ammo, even at the shooting range, ever since I learned how toxic it is. Barnes lead-free X-Tac ammo has worked great.
  6. pwesselius
    Report Abuse
    pwesselius - June 05, 2014 2:14 pm
    Lead is a potent neurotoxin that accumulates in the body over time and does not get excreted like other toxins. Lead was removed from paint in 1978, removed from (new) plumbing in 1986, removed from solder in food cans in 1995, and completely removed from automobile gasoline in 1996. Today, pending regulations seek to remove lead from Aviation gasoline (avgas). It comes as no surprise to me that lead is harmful to eagles. It's also harmful to humans and we should make an effort to completely remove it from our products. Solid copper bullets may be more expensive, but copper has better ductile deformation and it's a harder metal. I've been using solid copper ammo, even at the shooting range, ever since I learned how toxic it is. Barnes lead-free X-Tac ammo has worked great.
  7. Lou Ford
    Report Abuse
    Lou Ford - June 05, 2014 2:04 pm
    "Another ploy by that socialist Obama to come and get our guns."
  8. ttdad
    Report Abuse
    ttdad - June 05, 2014 12:51 pm
    More BS about nothing
Add Comment
You must Login to comment.

Click here to get an account it's free and quick

Ask the Times: Options may be available for asbestos removal

Ask the Times: Options may be available for asbestos removal

Q. Is there a grant to help remove asbestos from a single-family home in Davenport if you can’t afford to have it done? — Melvin

2 hours ago Photos

Photos

Related (0)

New diversion program in Davenport to reduce suspensions

New diversion program in Davenport to reduce suspensions

In a new effort to keep students from being suspended from school, the Davenport Community School District has tapped several partners — inclu…

2 hours ago Photos

Photos

(0)

Journalism professor: 'Don't kill the messenger"

Journalism professor: 'Don't kill the messenger"

Journalists represent the Constitution of the United States, and “the right to know,” a communications instructor said at a speech Sunday at S…

7 hours ago Photos

Photos

(0)

Quad-Citians show support for return of passenger rail

Quad-Citians show support for return of passenger rail

Quad-Citians are waiting to hear “full steam ahead” for the return of passenger rail to the Quad-Cities as work continues on a station where A…

7 hours ago Photos

Photos

(4)

Budget hearings wind down: Decisions ahead

Budget hearings wind down: Decisions ahead

MUSCATINE, Iowa — After nearly 24 hours of meetings over the past week on the city's proposed Fiscal Year 2017 budget, the City Council starte…

12 hours ago

Mayor, aldermen grapple with fire cuts

Mayor, aldermen grapple with fire cuts

Davenport Mayor Frank Klipsch's response to simmering frustrations over fire department staffing levels that were expressed to him and alderme…

20 hours ago(9)

Space heater caused Rock Island fire, survivor says

Space heater caused Rock Island fire, survivor says

Valencia Henderson said she is taking life one day at a time after escaping a fire that tore through her Rock Island home Saturday afternoon.

20 hours ago Photos

Photos

(1)

Caucuses, reliant on volunteers, succeed despite challenges

Caucuses, reliant on volunteers, succeed despite challenges

CEDAR RAPIDS — Planning for the Iowa caucuses can be like preparing for a winter storm not knowing whether it will be ice or snow or how much …

February 07, 2016 12:00 am Photos

Photos

(0)

Obama built bipartisan reputation in Illinois Senate

Obama built bipartisan reputation in Illinois Senate

SPRINGFIELD — Given the deep partisan divisions that have characterized his presidency, it strikes some as odd that Barack Obama is returning …

February 07, 2016 12:00 am Photos

Photos

(7)

High school robotics teams compete

High school robotics teams compete

 Davenport West High School freshmen Brandon Seamer, Zack Drumm and twins Ethan and Ben Gabriel watched Friday night as the robot they designe…

February 06, 2016 6:22 pm Photos

Photos

(0)

Fat-tire bikers dig in on Credit Island

Fat-tire bikers dig in on Credit Island

Ripping over the torn ground, mud splattering their day-glo outfits, nearly  100 bikers rode into Davenport’s Credit Island Park on Saturday a…

February 06, 2016 4:48 pm Photos

Photos

(0)

Bettendorf expo makes science exciting

Bettendorf expo makes science exciting

Adelaide Rhodes crawled through a colorful play tunnel that simulated the human outer ear — complete with a sheet of bubble wrap covering the …

February 06, 2016 1:23 pm Photos

Photos

(0)

'Operation Methed Up' nets 46

'Operation Methed Up' nets 46

It started in August with a tip about a possible methamphetamine lab in a Davenport trailer park.

February 06, 2016 1:00 pm Photos

Photos

(34)

Davenport board supports Tate's position against state

Davenport board supports Tate's position against state

Warning Davenport School Board members of the legal troubles they might face if they support his position, board president Ralph Johanson has …

February 06, 2016 4:30 am Related (0)

Gaul, Cullen honored with Iowa journalism awards

Gaul, Cullen honored with Iowa journalism awards

Quad-City Times reporters Alma Gaul and Jack Cullen were recognized by their peers on Friday when representatives of Iowa’s daily and weekly n…

February 05, 2016 8:00 pm Photos

Photos

(0)

8 things to know about Davenport's $201.7 million budget

8 things to know about Davenport's $201.7 million budget

Davenport city leaders are looking to pull a few more dollars out of the pockets of property owners and residents as it seeks to raise fees in…

February 05, 2016 7:00 pm Photos

Photos

(8)

Home show opens weekend run in RI

Home show opens weekend run in RI

The 39th annual Quad-Cities Builders and Remodelers Association Home Show offers just about everything you would need for your home and yard.

February 05, 2016 6:21 pm Photos

Photos

(0)

Audit identifies spending issues in Davenport fire accounts

Audit identifies spending issues in Davenport fire accounts

The Iowa state Auditor's Office said Friday it has identified more than $4,000 in improper or undocumented spending between 2009 and 2014 in t…

February 05, 2016 5:45 pm(0)

Scattered flurries and a low of 24

Scattered flurries and a low of 24

Good evening, Quad-Cities. Here is your National Weather Service forecast.

February 05, 2016 5:00 pm Video Related (0)

Clinton sheriff to run for re-election

Clinton sheriff to run for re-election

CLINTON, Iowa — Clinton County Sheriff Rick Lincoln has announced he will seek a fifth term as sheriff.

February 05, 2016 4:55 pm(0)