CASINO

RDA member: Davenport's casino site scoring process skewed

2012-12-05T04:15:00Z 2012-12-05T14:16:59Z RDA member: Davenport's casino site scoring process skewedKurt Allemeier The Quad-City Times
December 05, 2012 4:15 am  • 

A member of the Riverboat Development Authority board claims Davenport’s process for developing a land-based casino is skewed toward downtown rather than the city’s interstate corridor.

The email, written by RDA board member Chad Lewis with the support of board treasurer Don Decker, went out to board members Friday. In it, Lewis is critical of the scoring process for proposals, saying it favors a downtown casino.

Although the RDA and its president, Mary Ellen Chamberlin, will be involved in evaluating proposals, the email questioned the outcome based on the scoring system.

Lewis confirmed he wrote the email but declined to comment on Tuesday. Decker, who also is concerned about the project’s finances, said he favors a casino located along the interstate.

“The point system laid out by (Davenport City Administrator) Craig Malin is tilted in the favor of a downtown location,” the email states. “Mary Ellen stated we would be allowed to participate in the review process.

“Our participation won’t matter if the scoring template is already skewed in favor of downtown,” the email states. “This serves two purposes from the city side of the equation. They can claim fair play and look innocent when all the selected RFP’s (request for proposals) are downtown locations.”

Decker points out that the process allows points for not just “proximity to Quad-City population center” and “walkable access to existing attractions,” but also cost efficiency and time efficiency. That, he said, favors existing venues such as the downtown Radisson Quad-City Plaza and Hotel Blackhawk.

An addendum to the request for proposals lists 18 city-owned properties. Seven of those are located downtown, but four properties are located south of River Drive. The largest city-owned parcel downtown is the 3.6-acre Florian Kean parking lot.

City officials were unavailable for comment Tuesday, although Malin confirmed a response to the email is being drafted.

RDA board president Gary Mohr said the email is from one voice, and the board hasn’t taken a position. Chamberlin said the email shows a difference of opinion among board members.

“Everyone on the board has an opinion, but the board itself hasn’t issued an opinion,” she said. “Some favor an interstate location, and others favor a downtown location.

“There is some lobbying going on in there. Until the board acts on this, it is one person’s opinion.”

She admits that when the city worked with developer Steve Edelson on a proposed casino project, it was more willing to provide incentives for a downtown location.

Decker doesn’t think everyone involved is aware of the Iowa Racing and Gaming Commission’s support of an interstate casino and is suspicious that requests didn’t go out to all parties that requested them.

“I think some light needs to be shed on this,” Decker said. “I think it needs more transparency and honesty. I don’t think all the facts were given to aldermen.”

The RDA board is seeking more information from the city, and members are to submit questions to RDA attorney Bob Gallagher Sr. by Friday so they can be given to the city to respond. A board meeting where those questions are to be answered is scheduled for Dec. 14.

Copyright 2016 The Quad-City Times. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

(13) Comments

  1. sirius
    Report Abuse
    sirius - December 05, 2012 10:30 pm
    The Casino Rock Island probably wouldn't have passed this suitability test when the chose to leave downtown and build out by the interstate. And what has made this Davenport band of casino neophytes so much smarter than their Illinois competitors?
  2. katara
    Report Abuse
    katara - December 05, 2012 3:38 pm
    Maybe they could put it out at Rita Crudwells Horse Ranch. It would be fitting..
  3. Alloren
    Report Abuse
    Alloren - December 05, 2012 2:30 pm
    KJ, this is the most honest assessment of the casino deal I've seen, thanks. I have to note that its not coming from my Alderman or city administrator. It seems to me that downtown is coming along pretty well without an on shore casino, I'd like to see it become a vibrant marketplace like it used to be, but a casino in the old Parker block or else where in the downtown will just make a huge abyss where money disappears, not where it gets circulated. I want to defend the Times reporter a little bit, he is the only mediatype that is willing to ask even blunted questions about the deal. TV and Radio have all apparently drunk the koolaid, with what you've said about the Chamber I understand why.
  4. RIC
    Report Abuse
    RIC - December 05, 2012 1:31 pm
    Does all of this smoke screen and deception surprise anyone?
  5. levs
    Report Abuse
    levs - December 05, 2012 12:09 pm
    Another blunder by the Davenport City Council to go wtih such great moves as letting the race track go elsewhere, the bridge to nowhere and scenic road construction. Way to go!!!
  6. 1of3
    Report Abuse
    1of3 - December 05, 2012 11:00 am
    Sheri please seek help for your mental health issues.
  7. KingJoe
    Report Abuse
    KingJoe - December 05, 2012 9:30 am
    Parking is a huge issue for all downtown. Not sure how it's get better with a landlock Casino?
  8. KingJoe
    Report Abuse
    KingJoe - December 05, 2012 9:25 am
    .Either the times reporters are totally clueless or just they don’t care to understand this story. The casino is only going two places. It will either end up in the River Center or on Second Street where JA and the QC Chamber are located. The second is probably the forerunner. The Chamber is moving to Illinois….DONE DEAL…and the rest of the block long building is virtually empty. The real requirement however is where Restoration St. Louis wants it. They have the Black Hawk Hotel already so a River center casino (promised to them years ago) is fine but they also have the second street location under contract. A city owned downtown casino was and is the only goal. The oversight board is stacked in favor of the cities recommendation and to think this hasn’t been decided months ago is foolish. If this paper truly cared to dissect the Black Hawk hotel agreement between Restoration St. Louis and the City they could have seen this coming. Pay close attention to what the Hotel actually owns and what it gets to use for a nominal fee…The City owns the Gold Room, the Black Hawk rents it and the River Center runs it. All of this is public information and common knowledge to those of us who run downtown businesses. The City thought this was a pretty smooth process then Blackwell upset the apple cart by stating the obvious…5 million dollars extra is nothing to pay for an Interstate location if profits are the cities only motive. Then Bloomberg chimes in and basically says the city is crazy to saddle tax payers with this huge liability. Just ask yourself why the 5 million dollar clause is in the contract. The Isle was denied the ability to move to the highway in the first place; thus the penalty for the guy who does. I don’t think this can be stopped. The Chamber is in the tank for it. The City has skewed the requirements. I’m hopeful this will help my business but I’m thinking the wrong element that already plagues downtown will just multiply
  9. HROTer
    Report Abuse
    HROTer - December 05, 2012 8:38 am
    The city is the entity that will be taking the financial risk, the RDA will only - as usual - have its hand out. If the city has reasons for locating the casino where IT wants, it should be allowed to set the criteria how it wants. Period.
  10. Alloren
    Report Abuse
    Alloren - December 05, 2012 7:46 am
    According to the term letter approved by the council the city must give the Isle of Capri $5million more if the casino moves out side "downtown" Davenport. Does that skew it some?
  11. POPPY
    Report Abuse
    POPPY - December 05, 2012 7:45 am
    Of course it is a skewed approach... was from the start duh....
  12. GEM
    Report Abuse
    GEM - December 05, 2012 5:27 am
    There are some good points to having it downtown. During summer weekend festivities, many tourists go to the current boat for dinner or to get out of the heat.
    The Mississippi River is a big draw to out-of-towners when they visit downtown.
    The downtown area has some nice restaurants and hotels already, which could use extra business.
    A lot of older Davenporters, which make up a good part of the current casino visitors, don't like to go out to the interstate. It's much more convenient downtown.
  13. JS824
    Report Abuse
    JS824 - December 05, 2012 1:37 am
    Of course they're skewed. Gluba wants it downtown, and he won't hear otherwise. Gluba thinks Davenport ends at 4th Street.
Add Comment
You must Login to comment.

Click here to get an account it's free and quick

Arc director leaves legacy of service

Arc director leaves legacy of service

It didn't take Kyle Rick long to get hooked on her job.

43 minutes ago Photos

Photos

(0)

Candidates field questions on schools

Candidates field questions on schools

Seven candidates for an open seat on the Davenport Community School Board fielded tough questions Monday night from 40 residents concerned abo…

2 hours ago Photos

Photos

(0)

Catering company makes case for buying Hauberg

Catering company makes case for buying Hauberg

Bridges Catering made a strong pitch to the Rock Island City Council on Monday night as to why it should be allowed to buy the city-owned Haub…

2 hours ago Photos

Photos

(0)

Davenport School Board follows Tate's lead, risks legal action

Davenport School Board follows Tate's lead, risks legal action

Davenport School Board president Ralph Johanson admitted he woke up Monday morning feeling a “bit scared.”

3 hours ago(1)

Educators, lawmakers urge changes in Illinois school funding

Educators, lawmakers urge changes in Illinois school funding

  Many school districts across Illinois are sick and tired of it and aren’t going to take it anymore.

5 hours ago Photos

Photos

(0)

Authorities make cocaine bust in Bettendorf

Authorities make cocaine bust in Bettendorf

Authorities made an arrest and seized almost a pound-and-a-half of cocaine Monday in result of a several-week narcotics investigation, accordi…

5 hours ago(4)

Iowa Capitol Digest: Branstad addresses state's skills gap

Iowa Capitol Digest: Branstad addresses state's skills gap

A roundup of legislative and Capitol news items for Monday:

6 hours ago(1)

More snow and a low of 13 degrees

More snow and a low of 13 degrees

Good evening, Quad-Cities. Here is your National Weather Service forecast.

6 hours ago Video (0)

Proposed Scott County budget sees cut in tax rate

Proposed Scott County budget sees cut in tax rate

Fueled by moderate growth in the property values and an ability to hold down expenses, Scott County administrators are proposing a cut in tax …

8 hours ago Photos

Photos

(3)

Plan announced to reopen Illinois State Museum

Plan announced to reopen Illinois State Museum

SPRINGFIELD — Four months after the Illinois State Museum and its satellite branches closed to the public, the state Department of Natural Res…

9 hours ago Related (0)

1 dead, 2 injured in single-car crash near Eldridge

1 dead, 2 injured in single-car crash near Eldridge

Iowa State Patrol continues to investigate a fiery single-vehicle crash early Sunday near Eldridge that killed one person and injured two others.

14 hours ago(5)

Traffic alert: Accidents hinder I-80 travel

Traffic alert: Accidents hinder I-80 travel

UPDATE: Traffic on Interstate 80 is moving once again after crashes stopped traffic near the I-74 interchange in the Iowa Q-C and near Atkinso…

17 hours ago(0)

Bernie Sanders' SNL Cameo

Bernie Sanders' SNL Cameo

Democratic presidential candidate Bernie Sanders makes a cameo appearance on "Saturday Night Live" alongside comic Larry David. (Feb. 8)

18 hours ago(0)

Fire leaves 6 homeless in Muscatine

Fire leaves 6 homeless in Muscatine

MUSCATINE, Iowa — The American Red Cross is assisting a Muscatine family who lost their home to fire Sunday afternoon.

18 hours ago(0)

Police investigate single-vehicle crash near Eldridge

Police investigate single-vehicle crash near Eldridge

Iowa State Patrol continues to investigate a fiery single-vehicle accident early Sunday near Eldridge.

18 hours ago(0)

Ask the Times: Options may be available for asbestos removal

Ask the Times: Options may be available for asbestos removal

Q. Is there a grant to help remove asbestos from a single-family home in Davenport if you can’t afford to have it done? — Melvin

18 hours ago Photos

Photos

Related (0)

Mayor, aldermen grapple with Davenport fire cuts

Mayor, aldermen grapple with Davenport fire cuts

Davenport Mayor Frank Klipsch's response to simmering frustrations over fire department staffing levels that were expressed to him and alderme…

18 hours ago Related (28)

'Operation Methed Up' nets 46

'Operation Methed Up' nets 46

It started in August with a tip about a possible methamphetamine lab in a Davenport trailer park. Over the past several months, it has led to …

18 hours ago Related (0)

No injuries reported after shots fired early Sunday in Davenport

No injuries reported after shots fired early Sunday in Davenport

No injuries were reported from gunshots fired early Sunday in the 1400 block of W. 7th Street, Davenport.

18 hours ago Related (19)